Research on the Determination of Reasonable Compensation During the Patent Provisional Protection Period


Release time:

2025-01-14

李轶凡、李想

Preface:This article explores the determination of reasonable compensation during the patent provisional protection period from three perspectives. First, it compares the recognition of reasonable compensation and damages at the legislative and regulatory level. Second, it briefly analyzes the legal nature of the right to claim reasonable compensation from a jurisprudential foundation. Third, it examines the judicial logic applied by courts in determining reasonable compensation based on judicial practice.The author argues that the determination of reasonable compensation should be independent and distinct from damages. However, given the inherent challenges in quantifying compensation in intellectual property cases and the lack of clear guidelines in existing laws and regulations regarding the standards for determining reasonable compensation, the practice of courts basing such determinations on damages provisions is likely to persist in the long term.

I. Introduction

China implements an "early publication, deferred examination"system for invention patent applications. The patent provisional protection period refers to the phase between the publication of a patent application and its grant. During this period, the technical solution of the patent applicant is disclosed but not yet protected by patent rights, potentially allowing others to implement the solution without authorization. To balance the interests of applicants and the public, Article 13 of the Patent Law stipulates that after the publication of an invention patent application, the applicant may require entities or individuals implementing the invention to pay reasonable compensation (hereinafter referred to as "appropriate fees"). Furthermore, Article 18 of the Supreme People's Court's Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Patent Infringement Disputes (II) (hereinafter referred to as the "Interpretation II") supplements the provisional protection period system, specifying that courts may determine reasonable compensation by referencing relevant patent licensing fees.

 

However, the existing system remains ambiguous regarding the determination of ​reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period. Relevant laws and regulations provide only vague standards for calculating such compensation, lacking guiding principles and clear methodologies. In contrast, the methods for determining damages for patent infringement after authorization are more explicitly defined in existing laws and regulations, supported by numerous judicial precedents as guidance. In light of this, this article will conduct a comparative analysis of reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period and damages for post-authorization infringement. It will explore the determination of the amount of reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period from both theoretical and practical perspectives, aiming to provide valuable insights for legal practitioners.

 

II. Legal Framework Analysis: Reasonable Compensation vs. Damages

The existing legal framework distinguishes between the methods for determining ​reasonable compensation and damages. Article 18 of Interpretation II stipulates that reasonable compensation may be determined by referencing relevant patent licensing fees. However, Article 71 of the Patent Law provides that the second method for calculating damages is to reasonably determine the amount by referencing a multiple of the patent licensing fee, which differs from Article 18 of Interpretation II. Regarding why damages calculations require multiplying the licensing fee by a certain factor, some argue that using the standard licensing fee as the basis for damages poses no additional risk to infringers, potentially encouraging infringement. Therefore, determining damages as a multiple of the standard licensing fee reflects a punitive measure against infringers and serves as a deterrent to the public. Others contend that damages aim to compensate for the patentee's actual losses, not to punish, and that such losses include both profit loss and licensing fee loss. Simply using the reasonable licensing fee as the basis for damages may significantly deviate from the actual losses. Regardless of the interpretation of the "multiple of the licensing fee", the multiple referenced for damages is not equivalent to the licensing fee itself referenced for reasonable compensation.

 

Moreover, in the Interpretation and Application of Interpretation II, the Supreme People's Court explicitly stated that "the infringing acts stipulated in Article 11 of the Patent Law all occur after the grant of patent rights. By nature, the implementation of an invention during the provisional protection period does not constitute infringement. Therefore, Article 18, Paragraph 1 of Interpretation II stipulates that the usage fee during the provisional protection period may be reasonably determined by referencing patent licensing fees." This clarification demonstrates that Interpretation II considers the legal distinctions between the implementation of an invention during the provisional protection period and patent infringement. Accordingly, Article 18, Paragraph 1 differentiates the standards for determining reasonable compensation from those for damages for infringement.

 

Thus, whether based on the literal interpretation of current laws and regulations or the understanding and application of Interpretation II, there exists a distinction between reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period and damages for post-authorization patent infringement. Given this, how should reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period be properly understood? What are the legal distinctions between it and damages for infringement? This article will delve deeper into these questions from a theoretical perspective.

 

III. The Legal Basis for the Right to Claim Reasonable Compensation During the Patent Provisional Protection Period

It is widely accepted that the legal basis of the provisional protection period system lies in the principle of interest balance: during the period from the publication of a patent application to its grant, the public can access the technical content of the invention through the published patent application and benefit from implementing the invention. Since the patent application has not yet been granted at this stage, the applicant cannot demand that third parties cease implementing the invention. Based on the ​principle of interest balance, the Patent Law provides a form of "provisional protection" for patent applications after publication but before grant.

 

Further, what is the legal nature of the right to claim reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period? First, since the invention during this period has not yet been granted patent rights, it clearly does not fall under the protection scope of Article 11 of the Patent Law. Second, the right to apply for a patent primarily addresses who is eligible to file a patent application, and disputes over this right are confined to ownership litigation. Thus, the protected subject during the provisional protection period is neither patent rights nor the right to apply for a patent. Given this, what is the legitimacy of the legal basis for such a claim? In academia, the legal nature of the right to claim reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period is primarily explained by two theories: "unjust enrichment" and "conditional contract".

 

Viewpoint I: The Theory of Unjust Enrichment

Some scholars argue that the legal basis for the right to claim usage fees during the provisional protection period lies in the obligation of unjust enrichment. The applicant owns the technical achievements (non-prior art) involved in the patent application, and third parties benefit from using these achievements during the provisional protection period without legal justification. Such actions harm the applicant's interests, meeting the ​requirements of unjust enrichment. Therefore, the foundational right for the provisional protection claim should be the obligation of unjust enrichment.

Building on this, some point out that ​patent licensing agreements are mutually beneficial, meaning that a portion of the licensee's benefits rightfully belongs to the implementer. Thus, the standard for determining the fee under the provisional protection claim should be based on licensing fees.

Additionally, under the theory of unjust enrichment, beneficiaries can be classified as good faith or bad faith based on whether they knew their benefit lacked legal justification. For bad faith beneficiaries—those who obtained the technology through published patent documents—their restitution responsibility includes not only the benefits gained but also compensation for losses as permitted by law.

From this perspective, the nature of unjust enrichment also provides a basis for the current judicial practice in China, where damages for infringement are used as a reference when licensing fees cannot be determined.

 

Viewpoint II: The Theory of Conditional Contract

Some scholars argue that the right to claim reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period is a form of expectant right and conditional contract. From the moment the applicant publishes the patent application, they make an offer to the public domain. When someone implements the invention, it constitutes an acceptance, forming a conditional contract. The condition for this contract to take effect is the grant of patent rights to the applicant.

Under this theory, the implementer is obligated to pay consideration (which can be regarded as a licensing fee) rather than being subject to the restitution obligation under unjust enrichment.

 

Compared to the aforementioned theories on reasonable compensation, the determination of ​damages for infringement should exhibit the following characteristics:

  1. ​Infringement of civil rights
  2. ​Determinability of the damage
  3. ​Compensability of the consequences

Based on this, the determination of damages is guided by the "difference principle", which compares the victim's current financial situation with what it would have been had the infringement not occurred. The goal is to restore the rights holder to the position they would have been in without the infringement.

In contrast, the right to claim reasonable compensation is primarily based on theories of ​unjust enrichment or conditional contract, and does not involve the infringement of civil rights as in the context of damages. Therefore, it is difficult to directly apply the "difference principle" of damages to the determination of reasonable compensation.

 

Thus, the provisional protection period system is rooted in the principle of interest balance, while the legal nature of the right to claim reasonable compensation during this period remains debated. Whether based on the restitution of benefits under the theory of unjust enrichment or the payment of consideration under the theory of conditional contract, the purpose is to compensate the patent applicant for their legitimate interests. Under the unjust enrichment perspective, when the implementer acts in bad faith, they should bear a restitution responsibility that exceeds the benefits gained. The aforementioned theoretical perspectives on the right to claim reasonable compensation differ from the right to claim damages after patent authorization. Consequently, there should be distinctions in the determination of fees/amounts between the two.

 

IV. Current Judicial Practices in Determining Reasonable Compensation During the Patent Provisional Protection Period

Although reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period differs from damages after authorization at both the legal framework and theoretical foundation levels, such distinctions are rarely reflected in judicial practice.

 

First, Article 18 of Interpretation II explicitly states that reasonable compensation may be determined by referencing relevant patent licensing fees, but in practice, cases where such licensing fees can be referenced are extremely rare. Even when prior licensing fees exist, courts typically do not directly apply them but instead treat them as one of many discretionary factors.

In Li Mingyuan's analysis of 28 effective cases involving the calculation of reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period, it was found that judges primarily considered factors such as "patent type," "innovativeness," "subjective state," "duration," "product price," "sales volume," and "company size." However, only 3 cases used "licensing fees" as a reference factor.

 

Second, based on the author's review of cases involving reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period, when plaintiffs simultaneously claim damages and reasonable fees in the same case, courts handle the determination of reasonable fees in the following two ways, both of which show no substantial difference from the determination of damages:

 

Approach I: Combining Reasonable Compensation and Damages into a Single Determination

In most cases, plaintiffs simultaneously claim damages and reasonable fees in the same lawsuit. In such instances, courts may directly combine reasonable compensation and infringement damages into a single determination of economic losses. For example, in the case (2021) Supreme Court IP Civil Final No. 505, the trial court determined the plaintiff's economic losses (including usage fees during the provisional protection period and reasonable litigation costs) to be 1.5 million yuan based on factors such as the type of patent, the sales price and reasonable profit of the infringing product, the role and contribution of the patented invention in the infringing product, and the production period of the patented product. The Supreme People's Court upheld this determination in the second instance.

 

Approach II: Independent Determination of Reasonable Compensation

In some cases where plaintiffs simultaneously claim damages and reasonable compensation, courts independently determine the two, but the reasoning for determining reasonable compensation shows no significant difference from that for damages. For example, in the cases ​(2020) Supreme Court IP Civil Final No. 1858, (2020) Supreme Court IP Civil Final No. 1821, and (2018) Supreme Court Civil Retrial No. 3161, although the courts separately determined damages and reasonable compensation, their reasoning did not reflect any distinction between the two. Instead, they considered identical factors for both determinations.

In the case (2018) Supreme Court Civil Retrial No. 3161, the Supreme Court stated: "In this case, the trial court, based on factors such as the type of patent, the nature, duration, and scale of Huifu Company's infringing activities, reasonably determined that Huifu Company should pay 70,000 yuan as usage fees during the provisional protection period and 130,000 yuan as damages for infringement. This determination is appropriate."

 

Finally, the author's review also revealed that in cases where plaintiffs only claim reasonable compensation without seeking damages, courts still determine reasonable compensation by referencing the provisions for damages. Even when plaintiffs submit evidence of prior licensing fees, courts typically treat the licensing fees as just one of many factors, comprehensively considering other elements before determining reasonable compensation.

 

In cases where plaintiffs only claim reasonable compensation without seeking damages, if there are no licensing fees to reference, courts may directly determine reasonable compensation by referencing the provisions for damages. For example, in the case (2017) Beijing High Civil Final No. 55, the Beijing High People's Court stated: "Where there are no patent licensing fees to reference, the court may comprehensively consider factors such as the type of patent, the nature and circumstances of the infringing acts, and the established facts, and handle the matter by referencing the provisions on damages under Article 65 of the Patent Law." In this case, the trial court based its determination of the usage fee during the provisional protection period on the production volume, unit price, exchange rate conversion, and profit margin of the infringing products provided by the plaintiff. The Beijing High People's Court upheld this determination in the second instance.

When plaintiffs submit evidence of prior licensing fees, courts may treat the licensing fees as one of many factors, combining them with other elements for determination. The overall reasoning shows no significant difference from the determination of statutory damages for infringement. For example, in the case (2017) Guangdong High Civil Final No. 1997, the plaintiff submitted an exclusive patent licensing agreement with an annual fee of 500,000 yuan. The trial court ruled that this fee was not solely for licensing but also included technical support related to production processes, and thus should not be directly applied. However, it could be used as one reference factor. The court further considered the type and potential market value of the patent, the defendant's business scale, and the value of the infringing products, ultimately determining the usage fee during the provisional protection period to be 100,000 yuan. The Guangdong High People's Court upheld this determination in the second instance.

In the case (2009) Zhejiang High IP Civil Final No. 188, the patent licensing agreement submitted by the plaintiff involved a different patent from the one in dispute. Therefore, the court treated the contract amount as one reference factor, comprehensively considering the price and time of the products produced using the patented technology, the category of the plaintiff's patent rights, and reasonable litigation costs, and determined the usage fee to be 150,000 yuan.

 

Thus, in current judicial practice, courts do not distinguish between the determination of reasonable compensation during the provisional protection period and damages for infringement. In some cases, courts even directly combine reasonable compensation and damages into a single determination of losses.

The application of Article 18 of Interpretation II is extremely rare in practice. Even when plaintiffs submit evidence of prior licensing fees, courts often treat it as just one of many factors for determining reasonable compensation due to issues such as evidentiary relevance. The overall reasoning shows no significant difference from the standards used to determine ​damages.

 

V. Conclusion

From both legal framework and theoretical foundation perspectives, the author believes that the standards for determining reasonable compensation should be independent and distinct from those for damages for patent infringement. However, the distinction between reasonable compensation and damages remains largely theoretical.

In judicial practice, courts either directly combine reasonable compensation and damages into a single determination of losses or base the determination of reasonable compensation on the provisions for damages, without distinguishing between the two.

It is foreseeable that, given the inherent challenges in quantifying compensation in intellectual property infringement cases and the lack of clear guidelines in existing laws and regulations for determining reasonable compensation, the practice of courts referencing damages provisions to determine reasonable compensation is likely to persist in the long term.

 

 

Notes:

 

1 Article 18 of the Supreme People's Court's Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Patent Infringement Disputes (II): "Where the right holder, in accordance with Article 13 of the Patent Law, files a claim requesting a unit or individual that implemented the invention during the period from the publication date of the patent application to the grant date to pay reasonable compensation, the People's Court may reasonably determine the amount by referencing relevant patent licensing fees."

 

2 See Zhang Guangliang, Civil Remedies for Intellectual Property Infringement, Law Press China, 2003, p. 154.

 

3 See Cui Guobin, Patent Law: Principles and Cases (2nd Edition), Peking University Press, p. 883.

 

4 See Song Xiaoming, Wang Chuang, and Li Jian, "Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Patent Infringement Disputes (II)", People's Judicature, No. 10, 2016.

 

5 See Sun Qing, "Research on the Current Status and Improvement of the Provisional Protection System for Invention Patents in China", in Feng Xiaoqing and Jiang Fengtao (eds.), Research on Frontier Issues in Intellectual Property Law (Vol. 3), China University of Political Science and Law Press, 2017, pp. 309–310.

 

6 See Yin Xintian, Detailed Explanation of China's Patent Law, Intellectual Property Publishing House, 2011, p. 176.

 

7 See Li Mingyuan, "On the Determination of Reasonable Compensation in Patent Provisional Protection", Master's Thesis, Jilin University, 2023.

 

8 See Liao Tianjing, "Analysis of the Nature and Legal Basis of Patent Provisional Protection", China Invention & Patent, No. 12, 2013; An Xuemei and Zhu Xuezhong, "On the Right to Claim Provisional Protection", Presentday Law Science, No. 6, 2007.

 

9 See Wu Handong, "Market Value Analysis of Intellectual Property Damages: Theory, Rules, and Methods", Law Review, No. 1, 2018.

 

10 As previously cited in Note 7, see Li Mingyuan, "On the Determination of Reasonable Compensation in Patent Provisional Protection", Master's Thesis, Jilin University, 2023.

The Lingshi team has always been committed to providing professional intellectual property legal services to technology-oriented enterprises worldwide. We help clients protect their innovations, realize the commercial value of their intellectual property, and enhance their competitive advantage. Lingshi lawyers are dedicated to establishing long-term, stable cooperative relationships with clients, fostering mutual growth, and sharing success.

Contact Phone:

Address: Room 308, Area B, Block F, Vanke Times Center, No. 9 Wangjing Street, Chaoyang District, Beijing
Zip Code: 100102

Telephone: 8615801368068
E-mail:legal@lingshilaw.com

CN/EN

All rights reserved©LING SHI LAW FIRM   Powered by www.300.cn   SEO

Business License